Top Chef ™: Wisconsin
Season:
Week:
Cheese Elimination Challenge

The chefs were randomly assigned one of thirteen different cheeses. They were then asked to make dishes featuring their designated cheeses for a Top Chef cheese festival. The dishes were served to the judging panel and one hundred festival guests. The guests' votes determined the top dishes and winner of the challenge, while the judges selected the bottom dishes. The winner received immunity for the next Elimination Challenge. The guest judges were Carla Hall and chef Dane Baldwin.
Kristen Kish: "All right, chefs, for your elimination challenge, you will each be responsible for creating one dish featuring one of these incredible cheeses. Carla and I will join Tom and Gail, along with local chef and James Beard award winner Dane Baldwin and 100 cheese loving diners."
Note - 50% of the chefs decided to cook some version of a cheese croquette. In her affiliated TV show, "A Dish with Kish ™", Kristen Kish dedicated an episode to the Cheese Croquette. See our recipe and her commentary here.

As a family-run site, we pour our hearts into recording and transcribing cooking shows, developing tested recipes, and sharing culinary insights—all without bombarding you with ads.
Your low-cost subscription would help us cover ingredient costs and confirm that our passion project matters to you.
Please join our cooking community today.
Dishes prepared in
Top Chef ™: Wisconsin

Chef Charly: "I've got yuca (cassava) boiling in here. I'm going to make some yuca croquettes. It's going to be good. When I'm thinking about how to serve 100 people, well, croquette's pretty easy and awesome because you fry them, which means that every few minutes, people are getting fresh croquettes."
Chef Charly (presenting to judges): "So I made these yuca croquettes filled with the canela cheese. And then we have a tomato mango sauce on the side. Canela has a honey note to it that I think works really well with the fruitiness of the mango and the tomato sauce."

Chef Manny: " lived in ten different cities, but I have never lived in the midwest. I only know two dishes with cheese curds, poutine, and fried cheese curds. So I go with poutine with a potato croquette, cheese curds, and scallions. Good old pork fat."
Chef Manny (during prep): "I'm going to put the cheese on top. I don't want the croquettes to be gooey. I want to be able to fry them without them falling apart. I'm going to press them in between two sheet trays, and I'm going to let them cool down overnight, and cut them tomorrow, bread them, and fry them."
Chef Manny (presenting to judges): "We have a potato croquette, cheese curds, and beer gravy.
Kirsten Kish: "So there's no cheese curd in the potato?"
Chef Manny: "No, there's no cheese curd in the potatoes. Instead of having french fries with curds and gravy, I'm having potato croquette.

Chef Alisha: "I'm going to do a traditional spanish croquette with some smoked pork."
Chef Alisha (during prep): "I got brick cheese. So I'm doing a play on a ham and cheese sandwich."
Tom Colicchio: "When was the last time you made a croquette?"
Chef Alisha: "I make them all the time. I feel pretty confident in this dish. I mean, my cuisine is spanish food."
Tom Colicchio (laughing): "Okay, so you're making coquetto. okay."
Chef Alisha: "My culinary style is definitely inspired by coastal spanish food, but I live in the midwest. Nowhere near an ocean. Of course, the first time I feel like I can really represent myself, everyone else is doing the same thing."
Chef Alisha (presenting to judges): "The rind of this lovely cheese is actually washed in Merlot. My dish is ham and brick cheese croquettes with a sherry aioli."

Chef Kaleena: "I pulled a merlot bellavatano. It seems like it's going to have that beautiful melt that a cheddar does, but it has a much bolder, complex flavor. I feel like I got the best of both worlds with this cheese."
Chef Kaleena (during prep): "Don't judge my store-bought pasta, please. I'm cooking for 100 people. This is not the challenge where you're going to make a pasta from scratch. This is the challenge where you're going to highlight the cheese and get the job done. Not so much Mac and cheese. More like a play on Alfredo."
Chef Kaleena: (presenting to judges): "I thought everyone was going to be doing macaroni and cheeses, and then somehow I'm the only one. I used the BellaVitano in it. I wanted to bring out the flavors of the rind of the cheese, so I braised some mushrooms and some aromatics and merlot."

Chef Amanda: "I'm making some raclette aroncini. There's Mornay inside the aroncini, and then on the bottom is a Mornay and Dijon sauce and a little bit of fig and olive."

Chef Kevin: "So you have a sauce mornay with diced ham, chives, and on the top, you have a truffle paste made with mushroom and truffle."
Kristen Kish: "What was the breading? Just three step breading?"
Chef Kevin: "Yeah."
Tom Colicchio: "Why did you want to make a croquette with the cheese?"
Chef Kevin: :"Because for me it's the creaminess of the cheese. I just wanted to make melted croquette with truffle."

Chef Savannah (presenting to judges): "When I got Oaxaca cheese, my first thought was quesadilla, so I just kind of leaned straight into that. I have a white hominy tortilla made from scratch and cooked to order with a whipped avocado and hatch chili."

Chef Laura: "I picked Gouda. It's amazing. It's very nutty. Lots of crystals in it, so it's delicious. And I think it's perfect with the croquettes."
Chef Laura (presenting to judges): "I picked this beautiful Gouda Reserve that's been aged. I'm using the idea of a moustarda potato."

Chef Rasika: "I got the Dunbarton Bleu, and it's not a traditional blue cheese. It has more cheddar notes in it, and it's nutty. The first nut that popped into my head is hazelnut."
Chef Rasika: "I grabbed chicken thighs for cheese and rice cakes with a chicken gravy. There's a South Indian rice cake called paniyaram. Basically, it's a fermented rice batter. This batter takes two days for fermentation, but I'm trying to push it for 2 hours."
Chef Rasika (presenting to judges): "I had the Dunbarton bleu cheese. It's a cheddar blue. So I did rice cake. It's called a panyarum. I folded the cheese in the batter of the rice cake. I made a braised chicken thigh korma."

Chef Danny (presenting to judges): "I made Cheddar fritter with a cheddar lime mornay, and then the outside is a cheddar lime foam. I just try to highlight the cheese as best I could."
Kristen Kish: "Pâte a Choux and then cheddar inside?"
Chef Danny: "Exactly."

Chef Dan (presenting to the judges): "I was lucky enough to get a cheese from Door County, Wisconsin. It's Sancho Cruz, Manchego. I'm doing this with some potato dumplings. I've aerated the cheese and olive and charred scallion sauce, and then finish it off with some fried potatoes."

Chef Kenny: "I've got a little ponzu going with my crab. It's going to be a little crab salad. We're going to be serving in 100 degrees, so instead of doing another deep fried option with everyone else, I'm going to flip this crab rangoon on its head and make a salad with it."
"Normally, I use cream cheese, but this really creamy gorgonzola is going to go really well with this sweet crab."
Tom Colicchio: "Hey, Kenny, what are you working on there?"
Chef Kenny (during prep): "Light little maraschino cherry relish to go with my gorgonzola crab rangoon."
Tom Colicchio: "So what are you doing with the gorgonzola?"
Kenny: "I have made a creme out of it and made a little crab salad. I grew up eating crab rangoons, so gorgonzola feels a little more familiar to me."
Chef Kenny (presenting to judges): "Today I prepared a crab rangoon salad with a gorgonzola creme fraiche crema, little luxardo cherry relish, and chili hibiscus flake on a rice paper chip."

Chef Michelle: "I'm going to do a play on sag paneer. Kind of a coconut curry. Collard greens. I do not cook a lot of indian food. I do cook a lot of southern food. Sag paneer typically uses paneer cheese and spinach. I've decided to go with collard greens. It really just speaks to who I am. "
Chef Michelle (presenting to the judges): "I picked Pleasant Ridge reserve cheese today, and I did a take on a sag paneer for the coconut curry gravy. I have collard greens in there. The fritter is made of potato, more cheese, a little bit of curry, and cilantro."
Culinary Challenges inspired by
Top Chef ™: Wisconsin

Shadow beni (Eryngium foetidum) is a pungent Caribbean herb also known as culantro, Mexican coriander, or chadon beni. Despite its strong, almost overwhelming smell when raw, it's essential in Caribbean cooking, particularly in Trinidad and Tobago. The serrated leaves have an intense cilantro-like flavor but much stronger and more complex, with earthy, slightly bitter notes.
Cooking Tips:
Use sparingly: Shadow beni is potent - start with just 1-2 leaves and adjust to taste. A little goes a very long way.
Cooking transforms it: The harsh raw flavor mellows beautifully when cooked, becoming aromatic and complex without the intensity.
Perfect for slow cooking: Excellent in stews, curries, and rice dishes where it can simmer and develop depth.
Prep carefully: Wash thoroughly and chop finely. Remove thick stems as they can be tough.
Storage: Keeps longer than regular cilantro - wrap in damp paper towels and refrigerate.
Substitution: If unavailable, use triple the amount of regular cilantro, though the flavor will be different.

Cou cou is a beloved West African staple made from cornmeal and okra, creating a smooth, polenta-like dish with a distinctive texture. Popular across the Caribbean (especially Barbados) and parts of West Africa, it's traditionally served alongside fish, stews, or curries. The okra acts as both flavoring and natural thickener, giving cou cou its characteristic silky consistency.
Essential Cooking Tips:
Prevent lumps: Always add cornmeal gradually while whisking constantly. Never dump it all at once.
Use fresh okra: Slice thinly and cook until tender before adding cornmeal - this releases the natural mucilage that creates the signature texture.
Keep stirring: Constant stirring prevents sticking and ensures even cooking. Use a wooden spoon and expect 15-20 minutes of active stirring.
Season generously: Salt, pepper, and sometimes butter are essential. Some cooks add garlic or herbs.
Consistency matters: Aim for smooth and creamy, similar to soft polenta. Add hot water if it becomes too thick.
The result should be comforting, smooth, and slightly sticky - perfect for soaking up flavorful sauces.

Lamb spiedini are Italian-style skewers featuring cubed lamb marinated and grilled to perfection. Popular throughout Italy with regional variations, they typically combine tender lamb pieces with vegetables like bell peppers, onions, and zucchini.
The key to success is cutting lamb into uniform 1-inch cubes from the leg or shoulder, then marinating in olive oil, garlic, herbs like rosemary or oregano, and lemon juice for at least 2 hours. Thread onto metal skewers, alternating meat and vegetables for even cooking. Grill over medium-high heat, turning frequently, for 8-10 minutes until lamb is nicely browned but still pink inside. Let rest briefly before serving.
The marinade doubles as a finishing sauce when reduced in a pan with a splash of wine.

Tacos al pastor is a Mexican street food fusion born from Lebanese immigration to Mexico, featuring marinated pork cooked on a vertical spit (trompo) and served with pineapple, onions, and cilantro. For home cooks, thin-sliced pork shoulder or pork steaks work well, marinated in a blend of dried chiles (guajillo, chipotle, ancho), achiote, pineapple juice, and spices.
Since most home kitchens lack a trompo, achieve similar results by grilling or pan-searing the marinated meat over high heat for caramelized edges. The key is balancing sweet pineapple with smoky, spicy marinade. Serve on small corn tortillas with diced white onion, fresh cilantro, and grilled pineapple chunks. A squeeze of lime and salsa verde complete this iconic taco.

Cochinita pibil is a legendary Mexican dish from the Yucatán Peninsula featuring pork shoulder slow-cooked in a fragrant marinade of achiote paste, citrus juices, and spices. Traditionally cooked underground in banana leaves, home cooks can achieve authentic results using a Dutch oven or slow cooker. The key is the achiote paste (annatto seeds), which gives the dish its distinctive earthy flavor and vibrant orange color.
Marinate the pork overnight for maximum flavor penetration. Banana leaves aren't essential but add aromatic depth—substitute with parchment paper if needed. The finished pork should be tender enough to shred easily and pairs beautifully with pickled red onions, warm tortillas, and habanero salsa.
Low, slow cooking is crucial for achieving the traditional melt-in-your-mouth texture.

Pommes Anna is a classic French potato dish that showcases the elegance of simple ingredients executed with precision. Named after a 19th-century Parisian courtesan, this preparation involves thinly slicing potatoes and layering them in overlapping, circular patterns in a heavy-bottomed pan or special pommes Anna mold. Each layer is generously brushed with clarified butter and seasoned with salt. The dish is then baked at high heat, creating a stunning golden dome with crispy, caramelized edges and tender, buttery layers within. The key is achieving the perfect balance between the crusty exterior and creamy interior. When properly executed, pommes Anna can be inverted and served as an impressive side dish that rivals any restaurant presentation.

Saskatoon berries (also called serviceberries or Juneberries) are small, dark purple berries with a sweet, nutty flavor reminiscent of blueberries mixed with almonds. These North American native berries have been a staple food for centuries and work beautifully in both sweet and savory applications.
In sweet baking, saskatoons excel in pies, muffins, and pancakes, offering more complex flavor than blueberries with their distinctive almond undertones. They make exceptional jams and syrups. For savory cooking, saskatoons create wonderful glazes for game meats, pork, or poultry, where their natural sweetness balances rich flavors.
Home bakers love that saskatoons hold their shape well when baked and provide unique flavor complexity. They're particularly popular in Canadian prairie cooking and are gaining recognition elsewhere for their versatility and distinctive taste.

Pemmican is a traditional Native American preserved food made from dried meat (usually buffalo, deer, or elk) that's pounded into powder, then mixed with rendered fat and sometimes dried berries. This nutrient-dense mixture was historically essential for long journeys, providing concentrated protein and calories in a shelf-stable form.
While not commonly used in modern home baking, adventurous cooks might incorporate pemmican concepts into energy bars or trail mix recipes. The technique of combining dried proteins with fats and dried fruits translates well to making homemade protein bars or survival foods. Some outdoor enthusiasts still make traditional pemmican for camping trips.
Home bakers interested in historical cooking or creating high-protein snacks can adapt the basic principle using modern ingredients like beef jerky powder, coconut oil, and dried fruit.

Haskap berries (also called honeyberries) are elongated blue berries with a unique flavor combining blueberry, raspberry, and honey notes with subtle tartness. These cold-hardy berries ripen early in the season and have tender skins that make them perfect for baking applications.
In sweet cooking, haskaps work beautifully in muffins, pies, and jams, offering more complex flavor than regular blueberries without being overpoweringly tart. Their natural sweetness means you can reduce sugar in recipes. For savory applications, haskaps create excellent glazes for pork or duck, and their mild tartness pairs well with soft cheeses in tarts or galettes.
Home bakers appreciate that haskaps hold their shape better than blueberries when baked, won't burst as easily, and provide that coveted "something different" flavor that elevates familiar recipes.

Chokeberries (aronia berries) are small, dark purple berries with an intensely astringent, dry flavor that literally makes your mouth pucker - hence the name. Despite their harsh taste when raw, they're packed with antioxidants and transform beautifully when cooked. In sweet applications, chokeberries work best combined with sweeter fruits in pies, jams, or muffins, where added sugar balances their tartness and creates complex, wine-like flavors.
For savory cooking, chokeberries make excellent glazes for game meats, pork, or duck, where their astringency cuts through rich fats. Home bakers can use chokeberry juice or puree in marinades, or incorporate dried chokeberries into savory breads and grain dishes. Always cook or process them rather than eating raw - the transformation is remarkable.

In season 22 of Top Chef ™, Massimo mentions umeboshi made from elderberry, but strictly that's not a thing.
Traditional umeboshi are Japanese pickled plums (ume fruit), not elderberries. Ume are a specific type of Japanese apricot-plum, and authentic umeboshi are made exclusively from these fruits, salt, and often red shiso leaves.
Elderberries, while used in various culinary applications, are not typically used to make umeboshi-style pickles. Elderberries are more commonly used for jams, syrups, wines, and baked goods in European and American cooking traditions.

Cachapa is a Venezuelan corn pancake made from fresh sweet corn kernels blended into a smooth, slightly chunky batter with milk, eggs, sugar, and salt. Unlike hoe cakes, which use dried cornmeal and have a dense, sturdy texture, cachapas are made from fresh corn, creating a naturally sweet, creamy pancake with visible corn pieces and a tender, almost custard-like consistency.
While hoe cakes serve as savory vehicles for sopping gravies, cachapas are traditionally eaten as a meal themselves, often folded around fresh cheese or served with butter. Home bakers will find cachapas require fresh or frozen corn kernels rather than cornmeal, and the batter is much wetter, producing thicker, more delicate pancakes that highlight corn's natural sweetness rather than its earthiness.
Best dishes in this challenge
Top Chef ™: Wisconsin
Worst dishes in this week of
Top Chef ™: Wisconsin
Featured Recipes from Top Chef ™





