top of page
Monkfish with charcoal tempura cheek and caviar
Monkfish with charcoal tempura cheek and caviar
As seen on TV
Which Show?
Who made this dish?

Monkfish poached in smoked bone oil with horseradish sauce, charcoal tempura cheek and caviar


Inspired by one of the first British film noirs, On the Night of the Fire (1939), filmed in Newcastle. Conceived entirely as a black and white dish. 


Cal: "I wanted to do a completely black and white dish, so that's what I've done. So you've got horseradish sauce, salt baked celeriac, monkfish poached in an oil made from the smoked bones and then a charcoal tiny tempura, monkfish cheek and caviar." The monkfish is poached in an oil made from roasted monkfish bones, then given a light char on the barbecue. The monkfish cheeks are battered in a black charcoal tempura and deep fried. Horseradish sauce: sour cream base, horseradish oil, dashi as the foundation. 


Cal: "Oil made out of horseradish. Use a dashi base. So it's got a really high, nice salt content. It's intense, but it has to source the entire dish." A charcoal emulsion is placed underneath the salt-baked celeriac so it is released as the diner presses down through the layers. 


Cal: "The main bit of that is actually right at the bottom. It's under the celeriac. So as you press it down and cut through it all, you're going to get it on everything." Slivers of radish, black apple gastric, vinegar powder and caviar complete the dish.

VETERAN ROUND: Paul at the pass: "Let's start with the monkfish. Happy with the cooking on the monkfish?" Cal: "Yeah, nice and pearlescent." Weike: "Think of the fish as just a touch under the tempura." Paul: "The crispness." Cal: "Yeah, super crispy." Jamie: "I find the tempura is slightly oily." Paul: "Maybe it's an intense sauce. Have you got the balance of the sauce on the dish when you eat it with everything else?" Cal: "I think so. I think the balance is there." Jamie: "I think I'd go a little bit more. Because that sort of umph, that spice." Peers scored it 9 and 8. Paul at formal scoring: Score 9. "Cal, I'm going to start with you. For your dish, Black and White Newcastle. I loved your passion for black and white film. The monkfish was pearlescent and beautifully cooked. The horseradish sauce is intense. It's strong, but the way that you just froth it lightly, that's clever, that's intelligent." Host: "You captured film noir. It's very clever cooking. Really beautiful." JUDGING ROUND: [To be completed when judging round transcript is received]
What next?

Tell us what you'd like and we'll send what you pick.

Want the recipe for this dish?

Never miss a new recipe

Cooking along at home?

bottom of page