top of page
Paradise Lost: Anchovy Caramel
Paradise Lost: Anchovy Caramel
As seen on TV
Which Show?
Who made this dish?

Paradise Lost: Pandan Ice Cream with Anchovy Fish-Sauce Caramel & Black Sesame Shortbread Crumble 


Chris's 'evil' dessert. Voted least likely to win, Chris kept the toughest forbidden ingredient — anchovies — for himself. Chris: "This challenge is hard because you're trying to incorporate flavor that most people would not associate with dessert. Everyone in this room thinks I'm absolutely out of my mind because I picked anchovies. But I really like my approach. I'm gonna purée fish sauce with anchovies, strain it out, add that into my caramel. The anchovies in a caramel — first time ever doing that." 


On presentation: "For my evil dessert, I made Paradise Lost. The green pandan ice cream is supposed to represent the good, and then the anchovy fish sauce caramel underneath — it's kind of swallowing it up. And then I made a black sesame shortbread cookie with a little crumble underneath to represent fire and brimstone."

Wylie Dufresne: "We have all struggled with why on earth you picked anchovies. But 100% — you sold me. This caramel was really delicious." 


Nina Métayer (guest): "I really love the burning on top. It's make me — in childhood, when I was cooking the marshmallow." 


Padma Lakshmi: "I thought your caramel was really delicious." 


Michael Cimarusti: "I really enjoyed it. But I did think you were crazy for picking anchovies, and I'm sticking by that."

What next?

Tell us what you'd like and we'll send what you pick.

Want the recipe for this dish?

Never miss a new recipe

Cooking along at home?

bottom of page