Chef Samuel: "I made a tiger prawn carpaccio and prawn head emulsion sauce. There are different vegetables, and vegetable vinaigrette and a prawn cracker on the top."

Judging

Gail Simmons: "Samuel's carrots are cooked nicely."

Tom Collichio: "The vegetable work was actually pretty good."

Padma Lakshi: "But that fish just ate so slimy. "

Brett Graham: "I sort of picked it up and there it is. Poo pipe, if that's a professional word for it.

Padma Lakshi: "He didn't devein the shrimp." 

Other judge: "I got the same thing. Not very refined. He needed to clean it."